Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese Recipe

Looking for a grilled cheese that packs a serious flavor punch? This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese is what happens when comfort food classics collide in all the best ways—think spicy Buffalo chicken, creamy cheese, and buttery, perfectly toasted bread. If you love gooey, melty, bold sandwiches, this one will instantly become your new favorite!

this Recipe

Ingredients You’ll Need

What I adore about this recipe is how the simplest ingredients come together for knockout results! Every single component plays a key role—bringing heat, creaminess, crunch, or that signature Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese flavor explosion.

• Sandwich Bread: Sturdy white or wheat sandwich bread is perfect for holding all the fillings together and grilling to crispy perfection.
• Cooked Chicken Breast: Rotisserie chicken keeps things extra juicy and flavorful, plus it shreds like a dream for easy assembly.
• Minced Garlic: Fresh garlic wakes up the savory flavors, adding depth to the chicken mixture.
• Cayenne Pepper (optional): Want to amp up the heat? Just a pinch gives an extra Buffalo-style kick.
• Ground Black Pepper & Paprika: These cozy spices round out the flavor with subtle warmth and color.
• Frank’s Hot Sauce: You can’t have Buffalo chicken without it—it’s tangy, spicy, and absolutely essential!
• Ranch Dressing: Cool and creamy, ranch balances the heat while soaking every bite with irresistible flavor.
• Cream Cheese: For dreamy richness and melt-factor. Let it soften before mixing for easy spreading.
• Butter: Spread on the outside of the bread, butter ensures that golden, indulgent grilled cheese crunch.
• Sliced Muenster Cheese: This cheese melts beautifully, blending seamlessly with the bold flavors and adding those epic cheese pulls.
• Crumbled Blue Cheese: Blue cheese lovers, rejoice! It’s punchy, creamy, and takes everything to the next level (but see my variation below if you don’t love it!).

Variations

Making Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese your own is half the fun! There are so many ways to adjust this gooey, golden sandwich to suit your spice level, dietary preferences, or whatever you have in your fridge.

• No Blue Cheese: Swap the blue cheese for extra cream cheese, mozzarella, Colby Jack, or simply leave it out for a milder flavor profile.
• Add Veggies: Toss in mashed avocado, diced tomatoes, or finely chopped celery either in the chicken mixture or spread over the cheese—this adds freshness and crunch!
• Gluten-Free: Use your favorite gluten-free sandwich bread to make these irresistible for everyone at the table.
• Spice It Up or Tone It Down: Add extra cayenne or jalapeños for fire-breather level heat, or cut back on Frank’s for a mild, kid-friendly bite.
• Different Cheeses: Try Monterrey Jack, sharp cheddar, or provolone for new melty goodness each time.

How to Make Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese

Step 1: Mix the Cheese Spread

In a small bowl, combine softened cream cheese, crumbled blue cheese, paprika, black pepper, and cayenne (if using). Mash everything together until it’s creamy and well-blended—this is your luscious, tangy base for the sandwich. Don’t worry if it looks a little rustic; it’ll melt right into the bread.

Step 2: Make the Buffalo Chicken Filling

Take another bowl and toss in the shredded cooked chicken, Frank’s hot sauce, ranch, and minced garlic. Stir until every last bit of chicken is coated in saucy, spicy flavor. You want every bite of your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese to have a little zing!

Step 3: Assemble the Sandwiches

Lay out your bread and spread a thin layer of butter on one side of each slice—these buttery sides will create the dreamy golden crust. Flip four slices over and spread them with your cream cheese mixture first. Top with an even layer of the Buffalo chicken filling (about ½ cup per sandwich). Cover the other four slices of bread with Muenster cheese, then close each sandwich so the buttered side is facing out.

Step 4: Grill Until Golden and Gooey

Preheat a large skillet over low heat and give it a little blast of nonstick spray. Grill the sandwiches for about 5 minutes per side, or until beautifully crisp and golden on the outside and irresistibly melty inside. If your skillet is small, work in batches to maintain that perfect even browning.

Step 5: Serve and Enjoy!

Slice your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese sandwiches diagonally (for maximum cheese stretch, of course!), and serve right away with extra Buffalo sauce, ranch, or blue cheese dressing for dipping. Dig in while hot for the ultimate comfort food experience!

How to Serve Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese

Garnishes

This sandwich is a showstopper all on its own, but don’t skip the finishing touches! I love sprinkling extra crumbled blue cheese or a scattering of chopped scallions over each slice. For a pop of brightness, a little fresh parsley or chives goes a long way, and a drizzle of Buffalo sauce adds dramatic flair and a flavor boost.

Side Dishes

A Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese plays so well with crunchy celery and carrot sticks—just like your favorite Buffalo wings night! Potato chips, oven fries, or a tangy slaw are perfect sides, while a cup of creamy tomato soup gives you that nostalgic grilled cheese experience, but with a spicy twist.

Creative Ways to Present

Stack up mini Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese triangles for game day platters, or slice into bite-sized pieces and skewer with toothpicks for party-perfect appetizers. Sprinkle with fun garnishes and serve on a wooden board for a seriously crowd-pleasing centerpiece!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Leftover sandwiches (if you have any!) store beautifully for a day or two. Wrap your Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese tightly in foil and stash in the fridge—they stay crisp and the flavors just get better.

Freezing

While Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese is best hot off the skillet, you can freeze them after cooling. Wrap individually in foil, tuck in a freezer zip bag, and freeze for up to one month. The bread may get softer, but the flavor is still all there!

Reheating

For best results, reheat your sandwich (still wrapped in foil) in the oven at 350°F for 10-15 minutes—this brings back the crispiness and melty cheese. If you’re short on time, a quick microwave blast works, but plan for less crunch.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Buffalo Chicken Grilled Cheese is pure joy sandwiched between two golden slices of bread—spicy, creamy, gooey, and so satisfying. If you’re in the mood for a sandwich with BIG personality, this recipe is calling your name. I hope you’ll give it a try and fall in love with every melty, flavorful bite!

Print