Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe

If you’re looking to wow your friends and family this Halloween with a treat that’s spooky, yet utterly delicious, this Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe is exactly what you need. I absolutely love how buttery and crisp these cookies turn out, plus the almond “fingernails” give them that perfect eerie touch. Trust me, once you try this recipe, you’ll find it’s become a seasonal must-have in your cookie arsenal.

this Recipe

Ingredients You’ll Need

The balance of flavors in this Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe comes from buttery richness, a hint of cinnamon warmth, and the light sweetness of brown sugar. I always recommend using good quality butter here for that melt-in-your-mouth texture.

• All purpose flour: Spoon and level it for accuracy – this keeps the dough from becoming too dry or dense.
• Unsalted butter: Using unsalted lets you control the saltiness; also, softened butter creams better.
• Brown sugar: Adds moisture and a subtle caramel depth; I use light brown sugar for a milder flavor.
• Vanilla extract: Boosts the overall flavor profile, making these cookies irresistible.
• Ground cinnamon: Just a touch for warmth—don’t skip it; it complements the buttery notes beautifully.
• Kosher salt: Enhances all the other flavors and balances the sweetness.
• Slivered almonds: These make the perfect creepy “fingernails” and add a lovely crunch contrast.

Variations

I love that the Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe lends itself easily to tweaks so you can get creative every time you make it. Here are a few of my favorite ways to mix things up:

• Green Witch Fingers: I discovered this trick when I added a few drops of green food coloring to the dough during mixing—it instantly turned my cookies perfect for Halloween!
• Alternative “Fingernails”: Pistachios, pecans, or even candy-coated chocolate chips work great if you don’t have slivered almonds handy.
• Spiced Up: Adding a pinch of nutmeg or ground ginger with the cinnamon creates a cozy, fall-spiced version my family goes crazy for.
• Jam for Blood: For a slightly gory effect, add a dab of raspberry or strawberry jam at the fingertip after baking. Just wait to add it until serving to keep the cookies crisp.

How to Make Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe

Step 1: Cream the Butter and Sugar

Begin by creaming together your softened butter, brown sugar, and vanilla extract until the mixture is smooth and creamy, about 1 to 2 minutes. I like to use a stand mixer for this step because it saves my arm strength, but a hand mixer works just as well. The key here is that the mixture should be silky, not grainy—this sets up your dough to be tender later.

Step 2: Mix in the Dry Ingredients Gently

Next, sprinkle in the cinnamon, flour, and salt. Fold everything together gently until the dough just starts holding together. Don’t overmix here—you want to keep those buttery pockets intact. I like to turn the dough out onto a clean surface and press it together with my hands to form a cohesive square. If you find crumbly bits, keep pressing gently until it all sticks.

Step 3: Roll and Slice the Dough

Lay a sheet of parchment over the dough and roll it into a rectangle about ¼ to ½ inch thick—that’s the sweet spot for shortbread fingers. If you don’t have parchment handy, sprinkle a little flour on your rolling pin to prevent sticking. Then, cut the rectangle lengthwise in half and slice crosswise every ½ inch, creating lots of skinny finger-like rectangles.

Step 4: Shape into Witch Fingers

This is the fun part! Pinch each rectangle three times along its length: first about ½ inch from the top, then another ½ inch down, and a final pinch at the bottom. These dents mimic knuckles and give the “fingers” real character. After shaping, score three small lines across the bumps between pinches to add texture.

Step 5: Add Almond Fingernails and Chill

Insert a slivered almond at the tip of each finger to look like a creepy nail. If you prefer, try other nuts as I mentioned above. Once all fingers are shaped and nailed, cover and chill the baking sheet for 30 minutes or up to 3 days. Chilling firms the dough and helps the fingers hold their shape during baking.

Step 6: Bake to Perfection

Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C). While warming up, take the baking sheet out of the fridge for about 10 minutes to let it come to room temperature slightly—this little pause makes a difference for even baking. Bake your witches fingers for 9 to 11 minutes, or until the bottoms just start to turn golden. Resist the urge to overbake—they look delicate but need that light color for the perfect melt.

Step 7: Cool and Enjoy

Let the cookies cool on the pan for 5 minutes—this pause prevents breakage—and then transfer them to a wire rack to cool completely. Watching these cool is tough because the smell alone makes you want to sneak one, but wait because the crispness sets best when fully cooled.

How to Serve Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe

Garnishes

I often sprinkle a tiny pinch of cinnamon sugar on top before baking for an extra sparkle. If you’re going for the scary factor, a little red jam “blood” at the almond fingernail is brilliant and always gets a reaction from guests—just add it right before serving to keep the crunch.

Side Dishes

Pair these with a warm cup of spiced cider, hot chocolate, or even a pumpkin-flavored latte. For a festive party, setting up a creepy cookie platter with candy eyeballs and gummy worms amps up the fun vibe.

Creative Ways to Present

One Halloween, I arranged the Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe on a fancy black platter decorated with cobweb doilies and flickering LED candles. Another time, I wrapped individual cookies in clear cellophane with little red ribbon “bloody bandages” for party favors. It’s amazing how presentation makes these feel extra magical!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I store leftover witches fingers in an airtight container at room temperature and they stay perfectly crisp for up to a week. Just be sure they’re fully cooled before sealing to avoid sogginess, which I learned the hard way.

Freezing

You can freeze the unbaked shaped fingers by placing them on parchment-lined trays, freezing until solid, then transferring to a freezer bag. When you’re ready, bake them straight from frozen—just add a couple of minutes to baking time. I love this for last-minute treats!

Reheating

If your fingers lose a bit of their crispness, pop them in a 300°F oven for 5 minutes to freshen them up. The key is low heat to avoid burning but enough warmth to crisp the cookie back up.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Shortbread Witches Fingers Recipe quickly became one of my all-time favorite Halloween staples because it’s fun to make, gorgeous to serve, and downright delicious to eat. I love sharing these with friends who always get a kick out of the spooky design paired with that wonderful buttery crunch. Give this recipe a try—you’ll enjoy the process and the results, and maybe even make it a yearly tradition!

Print